CHAPTER II HISTORICAL OUTLINE— MESMERISM PRIOR TO MESMER.
The principle called Animal} Magnetism or Mesmerism being coeval with
man's existence, doubtless lay at the foundation of the otherwise inexplicable,
mysterious, and miraculous in the life and religions of ancient. people.
The following will serve to illustrate—"The Charlatans," says
Celsus, "performed extraordinary cures by the mere apposition of the
hands, and cured patients by blowing.
Among the Hebrews and
Assyrians these means were resorted to in the cureof
disease—"Naaman said, I thought he would stand and strike Ms hand [strike
up-and down in the original] over the place, and recover the leper" (2
Kings v, II). Spiritual powers, gifts of healing, prophecy, and leadership were
also conveyed by the apposition of the hands. "The Lord said unto
Moses, Take Joshua, the son of Nun, a man on whom is the spirit, and lay thy
hands upon him. Set him before the priest and congregation, and ask
counsel for him. And he laid Ms hands upon him as the Lord
commended" (Numbers xxvii, 18, 23). "And Joshua was full of the
spirit of wisdom, because Moses had laid his hands upon him."
Innumerable passages could be quoted from the sacred books of the
Hebrews in support of the practice, some of the effects approximating more to
the incidents of Modern Spiritualism than to purely mesmeric phenomena. These,
the curious can look up for themselves.
The prophets of Israel, or seers, were consulted in private
matters as well as the sacred things. In 1 Samuel (Chap. IX) you will find
Saul, son of Kish, consulting Samuel the prophet (paying him a fee too)
in order that he (Saul) might learn from the seer the whereabouts of his
father's asses.
Soothsaying, obsession, trance, visions, and inspiration were all
accepted facts among these people. The evil and the good depended on the
source. When Ahab, King of Israel, wished to know if he should be successful in
war and take Ramoth in Gilead, he assembled his prophets to the number of four
hundred. This was considered wrong,—as was also the action of Saul, seeking to
know his ultimate destiny and that of his kingdom from the spirit of Samuel.
Right or wrong, it is never doubted in the sacred record that Samuel did come
back and what he predicted did take place. With the Hebrews, Jehovah not only
spoke by prophet, revealed. His wishes through the seer, but He communicated
with man during dreams and in the visions of the night,
to warm "man of the evil he doeth, and to instruct him on the way he
should know."
" Healing by the laying on of the hands was common among the Jews,
and was practised by the Founder of Christianity and His immediate followers
with marvellous results. ''Many were astonished that such mighty works were
wrought by His hands" {Mark vi, 2). "Lay hands upon the
sick, and they shall recover"' (Mark xvi. 18). "The Lord granted
signs and wonders to be done by their hands" (Acts xiv. 3). As
illustrative of what I wish to point out in the light of modern science—held in
consistently by professing Christians.—Naaman, if cured, was cured by imagination
or suggestion, while the cures of Christ and the apostles are placed
in the category of effects which had no occult basis other than in the
'"dominant idea" of the "operator" and the
"expectancy" of the subject.
MESMERISM AMONG THE GREEKS.
The Greeks derived most of their customs from
India and Egypt
Medicine with them was a species
of priestcraft the mysteries of which the initiated
could not reveal to the profane
without sacrilege.
The first Greek physicians, for the cure of their patients, used certain
magic processes, which can only be compared to the manipulations of
the modern-mesmerist.
"The affections suffered by, the body," says Hippocrates,
"the soul sees quite well with shut eyes." "Wise physicians,
even among the ancients, were aware how beneficial to the blood it is to
make slight friction with hands over the body. It is believed by many
experienced doctors that the heat which oozes out of the hand on being
applied to the sick, is highly salutary-and-suaging. The remedy has been found
to be applicable to sudden as well as to habitual pains, and various species of
debility, being both renovating and strengthening in its effects-It has often
appeared, while 1 have thus been soothing my patients, as ifthere
were a singular property, in my. hands to pull and draw away from the affected
parts aches and
diverse impurities, by laying my hand upon the place, and by extending my
fingers towards it Thus it is known to some of the learned... that health
may be implanted in the sick by certain gestures, and by contact as some
diseases may becommunicated from one toanother."
According to Strabo, there was between Nepa and Fralea a cavern
consecated to Pluto and Juno, in which the priests slept for the sake of
the patients who came to consult them.
According to M. Foissac, the familiar spirit, the demon of Socrates,
that interior voice which appraised him of that which was to happen, and of
that which he should do, was nothing but a state of crisis or of natural
somnambulism with which the godlike genius was frequently affected.
In this I do not agree with M. Foissac. We have no record of Socrates
having been in a somnambulistic condition, natural or artificial. It were
easier to believe that Socrates had a demon, that is— a real sentient
(but spiritual) being who communicated with him—as he believed—than accept the
foregoing, or conclude with ML Lebut, 'that Socrates 'laboured under attacks of temporary insanity. Spiritual influences and spiritual faith were not confined
to the Israelites.
MESMERISM AMONG THE ROMANS.
Esculapius delivered oracles in a dream for the cure of his
patients. He breathed on the diseased parts, or allayed pain by the
stroking of his hands and often, as also did his disciples, threw his other
patients into long and refreshing sleeps for the recovery of health.
"I will not suffer persons" say Varro, "to deny that the
Sibyl has given men good counsel during her life, and that she left after death
predictions which are still eagerly consulted on all difficult emergencies. It
is recorded in St. Justin '"that the Sibyls spoke many great things with
justice and truth, and that when the instinct which animated them ceased to
exist, they lost the recollections of all they had declared."
According' to Celsus, Asclepiades put to sleep, by means of
frictions, those affected by frenzy. Where their frictions were prolonged,
the' patient was plunged into a deep" lethargic sleep. Heidenhain's
"cutaneous irritations" seem to be the legitimate successors of
Asclepiades, Motions. There can be no . doubt that the effects produced in
these and in similar instances were identical in character with the mesmeric phenomena
of to-day.
MESMERISM IN FRANCE. The modern Frenchman, like his ancient forbear, the
Gaul, is particularly susceptible to mesmeric influences. Its present day
hypnotic wonders are but the continuation, in another phase, of the higher
religious manifestations, which took place amid the mystic surroundings of the
Druidic temples. Women brought up and instructed by the Druids, we are
informed, delivered oracles, foretold the future, and cured diseases. The accounts given by Tacitus,
Lampridius, and Vopiscus regarding the Druids, bear testimony to the
confidence they had in the accuracy of their predictions. Endowed with
extraordinary talents, they (the Druidesses) cured diseases deemed incurable,
knew the future, and announced it to the people. In the Middle Ages "The
Churches" observes M. Mialle, "succeeded the temples of the ancients,
into which the traditions and processes of magnetism were consigned—the same
habits of passing whole nights in them, the same dreams, the same visions, and
the same cures, The true miracles performed on the tombs of the saints are
recognized by characters which is. not in the power of man to imitate; but we
must exclude from the list of the ancient legends a multitude of very
extraordinary cures where religion and faith interfered only so far as to
produce dispositions eminently favourable to the natural action of
magnetism."
A rigid and critical analysis of the records of the middle ages would be
here impossible, if not out of place, It would require a volume merely to name
the facts, from the exorcisms of Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus to the
convulsionaries of Saint Medard. Some intelligent men, one hundred years
before Mesmer, like their compeers of to-day, were disposed to deny the reality
of the miraculous, or to attribute their existence to magnetism.
"Magnetism," says Von Helmont, "is active everywhere, and
has nothing new but the name, it is a paradox only to those who ridicule
everything, and who attribute to the power of Satan, whatever they are unable
to explain."
In all times, as well as in all countries, extraordinary things have
passed for supernatural from the moment they are no longer admitted of
explanation; and it is natural to refer and attribute supernatural things to a
divine power. That which is esteemed supernatural and divine so becomes
the basis of religion. So we find in Pagan antiquity, in the middle ages, and
at the present time these phenomena inextricably
'mixed up with the history of religion.
Miracles (marvellous cures and misunderstood nervous and mental
phenomena) were dethroned by the savant in science and. philosophy and
attributed to magnetism 200 years ago. Even where similar phenomena occur, and
are admitted, magnetism—Dia or Zoo—is totally denied by the savants in the present
day, at home or abroad, and "the effects attributed to Animal Magnetism in
the past are now produced by "Neuro-Hypnotism," "reflex
action of the cerebral nerves", "cutaneous irritations",
"expectancy", "suggestion," "credulity",
"imagination" "stupidity," and other infinite
"isms" appertaining tothe nomenclature of modern science.
ANIMAL MAGNETISM, it is assured, is a psychological, mathematical point,
without form and void, having a location only in the superstitions of the
ignorant.
MESMERISM SUBSEQUENT
TO MESMER.
DR. ANTHONY MESMER was born on 5th May, 1734, in a small town called
Stein, on the bank of the Rhine, This celebrated man studied medicine, and
obtained the degree of doctor at Vienna under Professor Van Swieten and Haen,
and became acquainted with the virtues of animal magnetism by seeing the
wonderful cures performed by a Father Hehl, a Jesuit priest About 1750 this
young, doctor commenced to investigate the matterfor himself; and, having satisfied
himself of the reality of the cures made, he commenced a series of independent
experiments. Father Hehl's cures were supposed to be produced by the subtle
influence, or fluid of magnetism, which was imparted to patients from steel
plates and magnets prepared and used for the purpose. One day Mesmer, having
bled a patient, accidently passed his hand over the cicatrix, or lance
puncture, and observed that his hand produced the exact results which had
hitherto been produced by the magnets.
Mesmer, from the nature of his inaugural thesis. "On the Influence
of the Planets of the Human
Body," upon obtaining Ms degree might be expected to see a
relationship between the subtle influence exerted by the loadstone or magnet
and that of the human hand, and the adoption by him of animal magnetism, as
an adequate theory to cover all the phenomena created or experienced by him,
seems to have been a natural and easy conclusion.
Mesmer, having learned the art of curing disease from Father Hehl,
applied himself to the cure of disease with "extraordinary success."'
"He left Vienna,, and travelling throughout Germany and Switzerland
he continued to "work .wonders" his cures approximating to the
miraculous. Kings and Courtiers, as well as the people, vied with each other
for an opportunity to attend his levees and partake in his seances In
1778 he started for Paris; here his success in;curing disease was so remarkable
that the elite of society struggled for the privilegeof waiting
upon him and of learning his art A society was actually formed for the purpose
of acquiring his secret and; using it for the cure of disease.. Somnambulism
and clairvoyance had not yet been developed; by his process.
MESMER'S THEORY OF ANIMAL MAGNETISM. .
"There is a reciprocal action and re-action between the planets,
the earth, and animated nature.
"The means of operating this action and reaction, is a most fine,
subtle fluid, which penetrates every thing, and is capable of receiving and
communicating all kinds of motions and impressions.
'This is brought about by mechanical, but, as yet, unknown laws.
"The reciprocal effects are analogous to the ebb and flow.
"The properties of matter, and of organization, depend upon
reciprocal action.
"This fluid exercises an immediate action on the nerves, with which
it embodies itself, and produces in the human body phenomena similar to those
produced by the loadstone, that is polarity and inclination. Hence the name ANIMAL MAGNETISM.
"This fluid flows with the greatest quickness from body to body,
acts at a distance, and is reflected by the mirror like light, and it is
strengthened and propagated by sound.. There are animated bodies which exercise
an action directly .opposite to Animal Magnetism. Their presence alone is
capable of destroying the effects of Magnetism. This power is also a positive
power.
"By means of Animal Magnetism we can effect an immediate cure of
the nervous diseases, and a mediate cure of all disorders; indeed, it explains
the action of the medicaments, and operates the crisis.
"The physiciancan discover by magnetism the
manner of the most complicated diseases."
Mesmer had many disciples and ardent followers, among whom were some of
the ablest men of the day, such as the Marquis of Puysegure, Caullet de
Veaumorel, Petetin, Bergasse, Schelling, Von Humboldt, Ritter, Treveranus, Walther,
Hufeland, Echenmayor, Nasse, Ness of Essenback, Francis Bader-Kieser, and
Jussifeu, the celebrated botanist.
A Commission of Inquiry was appointed by the French Government.
The report in the main confirmed the reality of the phenomena, But the whole was
conducted in an unsatisfactory manner. The Commissioners could not agree among
themselves as to the basis upon which to begin their investigations. They were,
however, more or less agreed to this, that Animal Magnetism was thelast thing
they would give in to. Jusseu, the botanist already mentioned, a member of the
Commission, investigated the subject for himself. He pronounced in favour of
Animal Magnetism, adducing a great number of facts in its support.
The French Revolution, rather than any mistakes or vagaries of Mesmer,
or the unfavourable report/of the Commission of Louis XVI, eclipsed the.
popularity of Mesmerism in France for a time.
In Prussia the light still burned with a steady and brilliant flame. The
Prussian Government appointed Professors of Mesmerism at the various
Universities throughout the kingdom and established an hospital for the
Magnetic treatment of disease at Jena, the director of which was sent to
Switzerland to obtain from Mesmer the requisite instructions. The Scientific
Society of Berlin offered a prize of 3300 francs for the best explanation of
Mesmeric phenomena while the Governments of Russia, Austria and Bavaria passed
laws keeping the Mesmeric method of treatment as well as the medical treatment
of patients in the hands of the Faculty..
When the Revolution burst forth in France, subverting law, order and all
good, Mesmer returned, to his native land, where his time was divided between
persuing his favourite science and cultivating his estate. Here he was visited
by the most eminent men of the day; and 'before his death he had
the pleasure of seeing his works
edited by one of the Professors of the University of Strasburg, and his science
triumphant in Berlin, Jena, Bonn, Hale, Tubingen, St. Petersbeurg, Copenhagen,
and even in Vienna. In spiteof laws and law-givers Animal Magnetism
performed, the most wonderful cures. Dr. Malfati, one of the most talented of
the physicians in Vienna, adopted Mesmer's system, and practised it with great
effect.
Following Mesmer, the most active and intelligent of his converts or
followers was the Marquis de Puysegure. He pursued the practice of Mesmerism at
his estate at Buzancy, both as a study and recreation. One day, calling at the
house of his steward, he referred to what he had seen in Paris, where he had
attended Mesmer's lectures. Obtaining permission to mesmerize the steward's
daughter to his surprise and delight she was in a very short time thrown into a
sleep. He also succeeded, by similar passes, in mesmerising the wife of his
game-keeper. 'He was now confirmed in his faith, and became one of the
most successful mesmerists of his day. He was
the first to discover the
mesmeric-somnambulistic
condition. It happened in this way. He was mesmerizing a young man for
the cure of consumption. While making the requisite passes, the patient fell
into a peaceful—sleep—the true mesmeric sleep is exceedingly calm and'
recuperating. While in this sleep Victor talked with an intelligence rare to
the waking condition; and while in that state prescribed the remedies necessary
to his recovery. Numerous instances of a like character occurring under the
Marquis's influence, he at length, published a work on the subject and both on
his estate andat Paris devoted much time to Mesmerism for the
cure of disease, inwhich hewas eminently successful.
De Puysegure's views as to the cause of the phenomena were a slight
modification of those of Mesmer. He held views similar to those who believe in
organic electricity" and odic force. He believed that his subtle electrical
agent pervaded all space; all animated beings, and could be controlled and
directed by the will. By its skilful direction clairvoyance and
somnambulism could be developed in all.
Mesmerism at last found its way accross the channel Mr. Richard Chenevix,
F.R.S., published a series of papers on the subject in the London Medical
and Physical Journal for 1829, entitled, "On Mesmerism, Improperly
called Animal Magnetism." His experiments attracted the attention of the
Faculty—Dr. Elliotson, among others. Baron Dupotet arrived in London about
1831, and commenced a series of experiments—the Baron was a firm believer in
Animal Magnetism. These experiments were seen by Dr. Elliotson, who now
determined to investigate the subject for himself. The result of the
experiments of Dr. Elliotson, which was published in the Lancet, produced
a great sensation; and phenomena, which has been regarded as impossible, were
constantly produced.Prevision, introvision, sympathy, thought
transference, and all the extraordinary features of clairvoyance were
established.
Writing about this period, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, , the poet,
says:—"My mind is in a state of philosophical,, doubt concerning animal
magnetism. For nineyears it has been before me. I have traced it
historically, collected a mass of documents on the subject, have never
neglected the opportunity to question eye-witnesses, and my conclusion is that
the evidence is too strong for a candid mind to be satisfied of its falsehood,
or its solubility, on the supposition of imposture, or casual
coincidence."
The medical press teemed with incidents, demonstrations, and
experiments. Drs., Ellotson, Ashburner, Spillan,. Herbert Mayo, , and others
contributed. The Rev, Chauncey Hare Townsend published his celebrated tracts in
1840. About 1835, Dr. Esdaile's experiments in Calcutta attracted the
attention of the Indian Government Several hundred cases of severe operations,
mostly surgical, were performed on patients in the mesmeric sleep. The evidence
on 126 cases was laid before the Government. In ten cases reported on, six were
operated upon without any appearance of pain; one indicated movements
suggestive of pain, but declared he felt none; and threecould not
be put asleep. The commission appointed by the Government consisted of nine
medical men and a reporter. The report was conclusive, and entirely in favour
of Mesmer. As a result, a mesmeric infirmary was established in Calcutta, and
all medical students were to take a six month's course there before completing
their curriculum. What English physicians were slow to admit at this time—viz.,
the possibility of carrying out successful surgical operations while
patients were in the mesmeric sleep—was quite common to physicians on the
continent.
. A Mesmeric Infirmary was erected in London, and handsomely supported
by public subscriptions. Br. Elliotson threw his head and soul into the
concern, and brought with him all his ability as a medical man (being a, short
'time previously,Professor of
the London
University). Dr. Elliotson had a
greater percentage of cures and a smaller percentage of mortality than
any infirmary or hospital in London. By such practical results the curative
virtues of mesmerism were upheld in this country. In France, the Academy of
Medicine, Paris, in 1831, reinvestigated the subject of mesmerism; the result
was atriumph for Animal Magnetism, the report being fully in support of
that theory.
In France, Germany, Switzerland, India, and now in Great Britain, Animal
Magnetism was placed on. a scientific basis. In 1841 M. Le Fontaine, a French
man, visited England, and commenced giving public lectures on Mesmerism and
exhibitions of its phenomena. While in Manchester, he attracted the attention
of Dr. Braid, who was at first disposed to treat. M.Le Fontaine's experiments
as so much imposture. Eventually he admitted the truth of the phenomena with a
new theory of his own, which he called Hypnotism. Dr. Braid's
experiments were remarkable, Although both he and they were ignominiously
ignored by the Medical section of the British Association of Science in 1842,
it is only right to say that the individual members of the Association gave Dr.
Braid great credit for his researches. Heidenhain and Charcot in some respects
follows at a distance Dr. Braid. They merely dispute the theory of Animal
Magnetism, and attribute the phenomena to monotony, imitation, touch, and
imagination— setting up one theory to refute another. Since Dr. Braid published
his work, "Neury-hypnology, or the Rational of the Nervous Sleep,"
1843, numerous other authors and lecturers have made their appearance, among
the most successful of whom were Spencer T. Hall (the Sherwood Forester,
author, poet and physician) and Capt. Hudson, of Swan sea. These two gentlemen,
more than any other, created great interest in the subject Henry G. Atkinson
and Miss Martineau added to the public interest by their letters and
publications, In Scotland, Darling Lewis, Stone, and J. W. Jackson, as
experimenters and lecturers, aroused public attention.
There are
many living now who were delighted and captivated by the experiments of
the gentlemen named..
Mesmerism, by its present-day phenomena, will help us largely to
understand past mysteries, none the less real
because calm and thoughtful
scientific-investigation furnishes us with a hypothesis—if not:
sufficiently adequate to cover the whole ground, at least will lead us to see what can be explained on the
natural, or within the realm of law, and not beyond it, But of this each reader
must judge for him or herself. One thing is certain. Absolute knowledgeof w that is possible or not within natural law is
not possible to the understanding, unless what is infinite can be apprehended
by the finite. It is only when man
In his arrogance or ignorance declares he has discovered the confines of the
natural, that he seeks to explain by the supernatural whatever he esteems
not possible within the natural. The learned Athenians were "too
superstitious." There are learned moderns of whom the same might be said
With some all is matter, no matter what; with others-all is spirit,
matter being its temporary projection on a physical plane—"Chaotic ether atoms reduced to cosmos;" while
with others there is the conceptionand perception of the material and
the spiritual—of matter and of spirit—as distinct -as death and life— the
inorganic and the organic.
The spiritual may have its basis in mind, mind in organism, organism in
protoplasm. If protoplasm is
the physical basis of life and mind in animated nature, what is the
vitalizing essential-spirit or what—which is the basisof protoplasm? Shall I say I don't know what
matter or mind, or life, or spirit is? I know not, save by their manifestations. Magnetism—electricity—can neither be
defined nor known, only as interpreted' by law of manifestation. If we find a force in man
or in animals analogous in its
manifestation, to magnetism in a
stone—i.e. attractive and repellent forces —polarity—we are justified in calling that force Animal Magnetism for wantof a better
name. It is in this
sense the word is used by mesmerists. The
existence of such an influence has been denied, because similar or
apparently similar phenomena have been induced by persons who did not believe
in Animal Magnetism. That, perhaps, does not amount to much, seeing that these
objectors believed they Mad and have power to induce the phenomena by
adopting other means. They thus exercise their WILL-POWER and exert their
INFLUENCE by their POSITIVE assumption of another hypothesis all the same. I
believe in Animal Magnetism, From long practice i haveseen much to induce me to
realize and demonstrate that man can exercise such a force—a Force. which, in.
its nature and character, is no more occult than nerve force, magnetism,
light, heat, or electricity. All mesmeric phenomena, it is true, can not be
traced to Animal Magnetism. If successfully traced to secondary
causes—hypnotism, suggestion, imitation, and what not—it is a matter of really
little importance, so long as the whole phenomena can be lifted out of the
misty superstitions and vulgar exaggerations of the past and present, out of
the darkness of fraud and self-deception, into the light of truth and fact, by
investigation and demonstration. In the next chapter I shall deal with
"Modes of Procedure."
|